*By all standards, Chip Reese is the greatest professional poker player of all time. He has won millions in cash games, millions in tournaments, What makes a good poker player?. A relatively important question that comes up a lot in sports is, “Who's the best poker player of all time”? For a long time, people have carried. American Johnny Moss was one of the initial inductees into the Poker Hall of Fame and for good reason. Born in he was one of the greatest poker players.